Summary

The 3rd Automotive CFD Prediction Workshop was held on the 22th-23rd September 2022 in a hybrid format - virtually and in Barcelona, Spain. Two test-cases were studied; Windsor body and the DrivAer Notchback (detailed underbody with no rolling road or rotating wheels) as well as an additional geometry containing a front deflector to assess the ability to predict geometry deltas as well as the absolute numbers and flow fields correctly. Meshes were created for all cases in major grid formats i.e OpenFOAM, STAR-CCM+, Fluent, CGNS in addition to geometry and surface meshes. Participants who submitted results were allocated a 15 minute presentation slot.

Test-cases

Case 1

Case 1 is the Windsor Squareback body at 2.5 degrees yaw. In comparison to the second workshop, the test case has been simplified to be just the original no wheels model and to only require meshes with a high y+ and a wall function type boundary condition. The problem is at a Reynolds number of 3 million based on vehicle length and is within a wind-tunnel like domain. As well as force, moment and surface pressure data, there is also available non intrusive PIV measurements in the wake. The baseline grid is similar to the ‘eddy resolving’ grid from the second workshop and contains 37 million cells. The alternate grids halve and double the core cell size to give 7 million and 197 million cell grids. The grid type follows the second workshop using the ‘trimmer mesh’ and prism layer approach from Simcenter STAR-CCM+. The test description can be found here. The submission guidelines can be found here. Example data submission folder can be found here too. Grids are available in a variety of formats below.

Case 2

Case 2 is the notchback version of the DrivAer. Beside the base variant of the DrivAer (Case 2a) which has been analyzed in the 2nd Automotive CFD Prediction Workshop a variant of the DrivAer (Case 2b), which features a front wheel air deflector, has been proposed for the 3rd workshop. A detailed description of both DrivAer test cases is available here and, for the base variant, from the SAE Technical Paper 2021-01-0958 by Hupertz et al.. For both DrivAer variants the workshop will focus on a closed cooling configuration with static wheels and static floor. A comprehensive set of experimental data from the Pininfarina Wind Tunnel (Courtesy of Ford) including aerodynamic forces, surface pressure, velocity profiles and 2D flowfield measurements will be available for both DrivAer variants for the correlation of CFD analyses presented at the workshop. Please see below for the meshes which were created using ANSA by BETA-CAE Systems. The mesh of the base variant (Case 2a) is identical to the “Case 2 – Wall-Function Grid” used in the 2nd workshop. The Case 2b mesh is identical to the Case 2a mesh except for the front wheel air deflector region. The post-processing excel spreadsheet to enter your results can be found here. Also the grid files for flowfield mapping in ANSA and Nastran format can be found here.

Documents

Test-case description
Example submission folder
Submission guidelines

Grids

Case 1
Surface grids (windsor body) STL JT    
Surface grids (pins-only) STL JT    
Coarse Grids CGNS OpenFOAM Fluent STAR-CCM+
Medium Grids (baseline) CGNS OpenFOAM Fluent STAR-CCM+
Fine Grids CGNS OpenFOAM Fluent STAR-CCM+
Case 2
Case 2a Surface STL ANSA JT Nastran
Case 2b Surface STL ANSA JT Nastran
Case 2a Volume (Wall-function) CGNS CFD++ Fluent OpenFOAM
Case 2a Volume (Low-Re grid) CGNS CFD++ Fluent OpenFOAM
Case 2b Volume (Wall-function) CGNS CFD++ Fluent OpenFOAM
Case 2b Volume (Low-Re grid) CGNS CFD++ Fluent OpenFOAM

Agenda

Final Agenda for the workshop is here

Results Dashboard

The interactive results dashboard can also be found here

Presentations

Case 1 description and cross-plotting - Gary Page (Loughborough University) Slides Video
Case 2 description and cross-plotting - Burkhard Hupertz (Ford Motor Company) Slides Video
Dashboard Video Demo (Astrid Walle - Neural Concept) Video
Giorgio Giangasperio - Siemens Digital Industries Software Slides Video
Miguel Class - TotalSim US Slides Video
Astrid Walle - Neural Concept Slides Video
Ivor Annetts - Bramble CFD/TotalSim UK Slides Video
Tom Fahner - ActiFlow/Lightyear Slides Video
Sanjin Saric - AVL Slides Video
Olivier Thiry - Cadence Design Systems Slides Video
Emmanuel Guilmineau - CNRS - Centrale Nantes Slides Video
Jan Pischinger and Bastian Morcinkowski - FEV Slides Video
Rob Winstanley and Christina Peristeri - ANSYS Slides Video
Paul Norman - Ford Motor Company Slides Video
Francesco Fabio Semeraro - Politecnico di Milano Slides Video
CJ Doolittle - FlexCompute Slides Video
Eugen Riegel - Numeric Systems GmbH Slides Video
Gary Page - Loughborough University Slides Video
B. Eiximeno - Barcelona Supercomputing Center Slides Video
Neil Ashton - Amazon Web Services Slides Video
Håkon Strandenes and Florian Schwertfirm - Kreuzinger und Manhart Turbulenz GmbH Slides Video
Dr. Eric Jacuzzi and Chris Popiela - NASCAR Slides Video

Organizers

  • Oriol Lehmkuhl (Barcelona Supercomputing Center) - Local Organiser
  • Herbert Owen (Barcelona Supercomputing Center) - Local Organiser
  • Gary Page (Loughborough University)
  • Burkhard Hupertz (Ford)
  • Astrid Walle (Neural Concept)
  • Neil Ashton (Amazon Web Services / University of Oxford)
  • Charles Mockett (Upstream CFD)
  • Lian Duan (Ohio State University)
  • Timo Kuthada (FKFS)
  • Simone Sebben (Chalmers University)
  • Charles Ribes (Stellantis)
  • Iraj Mortazavi (CNAM)
  • Vangelis Skaperdas (BETA-CAE Systems)
  • Martin Passmore (Loughborough University)